By Nick Gardner
•
October 22, 2026
Are You Giving Your Team Enough Room to Lead? I once coached a pastor who had built an incredible church. He was confident, decisive, and a strong directional leader. He knew where he wanted to go and how to get people moving in that direction. And for years, that leadership produced tremendous results. But something wasn't working anymore. The church had grown significantly, yet they were beginning to hit a ceiling. As we dug into his Integrus360 results and what was happening across the organization, a pattern started to emerge. His team didn't know how to make decisions without him. It wasn't necessarily that he was micromanaging everyone. In fact, his ability to provide strong direction had been one of his greatest strengths. But over time, that same strength had created an unintended consequence. He had become the person everyone looked to for answers. And when the leader is always the one with the answers, the team never has to learn how to find them. I remember challenging him with a question: What happens to this organization when you're no longer the one leading it? If everything we've built depends on our ability to make every decision, have we really developed a team that can carry the mission forward? That's one of the reasons I spend so much time coaching leaders around two behaviors measured by the Integrus360: Willingness to Defer and Restraint. They're different behaviors, but both influence whether the people around us have opportunities to contribute, grow, and lead. Your Team Needs Both a Compass and a Campfire The Willingness to Defer dial measures how we collaborate, empower others, and share decision-making authority. Some leaders naturally take charge. Others are more comfortable stepping back and letting the team lead. Both approaches have strengths, and both can create problems when used in the wrong situations. One of the illustrations I use when coaching leaders is the difference between being a compass and being a campfire. A compass provides direction. This kind of leader helps their team understand where they're going, what needs to happen, and how to get there. Some people on your team need that kind of leadership. Maybe they're new to the organization or learning a responsibility they've never handled before. They need clear expectations, guidance, and someone who can help them understand what success looks like. But when you lead your most experienced, capable people the same way, your strength as a directional leader can become a constraint. Those people don't necessarily need you to tell them what to do. They need you to create space for them to contribute. They need you to become the campfire. Instead of providing every answer, campfire leaders gather the team around decisions. They invite perspectives, encourage collaboration, and help others develop solutions. They ask, "What do you think we should do?" And then they actually listen. That part is important because if you don't genuinely want their input, your team will know. Of course, the opposite problem exists too. I've coached highly capable leaders who are so willing to accommodate others that they say yes to responsibilities they should be giving away. They can do the work. They might even do it better than anyone else. But just because you can do something doesn't mean you should. Every time we step in to rescue someone from a responsibility they're capable of handling, we may be robbing them of an opportunity to grow. Healthy Willingness to Defer isn't about always stepping back. It's about recognizing when your leadership is needed and when someone else needs room to lead. Someone Once Made Room for My Voice I learned something about this long before I became an executive coach. About 15 years ago, I was an intern sitting in high-level strategic meetings with the founder of the organization. I was the note-taker. I didn't have the experience or knowledge of the other people sitting around that table. Frankly, I was just trying to keep up. But every so often, this leader would turn to me and ask, "Nick, what do you think we should do?" I remember thinking, Why are you asking me? I'm just the intern! But he kept asking. And when I finally offered an idea, he didn't immediately dismiss it. He asked questions. He wanted me to explain my thinking. He gave my ideas room to develop. Now, let me be clear. Most of those ideas were terrible, and we didn't implement any of them. But something important was happening. He was helping me discover my voice. He understood that developing a leader isn't simply about getting the best answer in the moment. It's about helping someone become capable of contributing better answers in the future. Fifteen years later, I can still see the impact of those conversations. He was practicing Willingness to Defer by making room for my contribution, and in doing so, he was helping me develop the confidence to speak up. Not everyone gets a vote in every decision, but he taught me that everyone should have a voice. And when healthy leaders make room for those voices, they develop something far more valuable than a team that simply follows instructions. They develop people who can think for themselves and lead others. Are You Listening, or Just Waiting to Respond? Now, let's talk about the other side of this conversation. Where Willingness to Defer influences how we invite others to contribute, Restraint influences how we filter and communicate our own thoughts. Some leaders have a thin filter. They think something, and they say it. They're quick to share opinions, challenge ideas, and react to what's happening around them. That can bring energy, honesty, and momentum to a team. But without intentional restraint, those same behaviors can shut down the people around them. I've coached leaders who were so quick to speak that their teams rarely had a chance to contribute. Over time, this behavior communicates to others that their contribution is not needed or worse, not valuable. One of the simplest adjustments I've challenged a leader to make was to stop being the first person to speak in meetings. Instead, I encouraged him to wait until at least two other people had spoken. It sounds like such a small thing, doesn't it? But when the strongest voice in the room stops going first, other people begin sharing ideas, thinking through solutions, and developing confidence in their contributions. We have a phrase we use with strong directional leaders: Listen without loading your gun. This means that you should not spend the entire time someone is talking preparing to shoot down their idea. Instead, listen to understand, and pay attention to what your body language communicates. Your team can usually tell when you've already decided their idea isn't going anywhere. We're not always as good at controlling our faces as we think we are! As a leader, sometimes the greatest contribution you can make to a conversation is to create room for someone else's contribution. Restraint Doesn't Always Mean Saying Less Now, there's another side to this. Some leaders have such a thick filter that they hold on to their thoughts far too long. They process, reconsider, refine, and process some more. Sometimes they're afraid of getting something wrong. Other times, they're detail-oriented people who want their thoughts fully developed before sharing them. The trouble is, while they're working toward the perfect response, the opportunity to contribute may be passing them by. I've coached leaders who had valuable insights but wouldn't share them until the meeting was over. Or they'd wait until they could speak privately with someone, only to discover the decision had already been made. I've encouraged those leaders to get version one of their thinking out into the room. Your ideas don't have to be perfectly formed to be valuable. But there's another way excessive Restraint can hurt your leadership, and I think it's even more costly. It can keep you from having hard conversations that need to happen. Maybe someone on your team isn't meeting expectations. You know you need to address it, but you start talking yourself out of it. Maybe I'm being too critical. It's really not that big of a deal. They've got a lot going on right now. I'll give it another week and see if things improve. We can become incredibly good at justifying our silence, especially when the alternative is an uncomfortable conversation. And sometimes we convince ourselves that withholding difficult feedback is the kinder response. But what happens when the problem continues? When expectations remain unclear? When frustration builds and eventually spills out in a way that's far more damaging than an honest conversation would have been? We're not actually helping anyone by avoiding what needs to be said. True kindness isn't avoiding difficult conversations. It's caring enough to have them with honesty and respect. Healthy Restraint isn't simply about developing a stronger or thinner filter. It's about learning when to pause, when to speak, and how to communicate in a way that helps people move forward. Small Adjustments Can Change What Your Team Experiences You don't have to completely change your personality to become a healthier leader. Sometimes growth begins with a small, intentional adjustment. Maybe it's asking a capable teammate what they recommend instead of immediately providing the answer. Maybe it's giving someone the authority to make a decision without your approval. Maybe it's waiting until two other people have spoken before sharing your opinion. Maybe it's speaking up, even when your idea isn't fully developed. Or maybe it's finally having that difficult conversation you've been avoiding. These behaviors matter even more when the pressure is high. Under stress, some leaders take control of everything. Others avoid making decisions. Some speak without thinking, while others withdraw, avoid conflict, or keep everything bottled up until it eventually spills out. None of these responses consistently gives your team what it needs. Healthy leadership requires us to recognize our natural tendencies and intentionally choose a response that serves the people we're leading. Willingness to Defer is about knowing when to provide direction and when to give others room to lead. Restraint is about knowing when to speak, when to listen, and how to communicate with intention. Both require humility. Both require practice. And both have consequences that extend far beyond us. Because I believe deeply that personal growth is never just personal. When we grow as leaders, the people around us experience the benefits. And when we neglect our growth, they experience the consequences. Think about that for a moment. If we're always making the decisions, our teams may never develop the confidence to make their own. If we're always the first to speak, we may never hear the great ideas others have to offer. And if we consistently avoid saying what needs to be said, we leave people without the honesty and clarity they need to succeed. The goal of leadership isn't to become the person everyone depends on for every answer. It's to develop people who can think, contribute, make decisions, and lead with confidence. Sometimes that means stepping forward. Sometimes it means stepping aside. Sometimes it means speaking up. Sometimes it means listening. The more intentional we become about making those choices, the more room we create for the people around us to grow. And isn't that what healthy leadership is all about? Nick Gardner Executive Coach Integrus Leadership Start Practicing Healthier Leadership Today It's one thing to recognize where your leadership could be healthier. It's another to know what to do differently the next time you're in the middle of a challenging situation. That's why we've created two free resources to help you turn these ideas into practical leadership habits. Do you struggle to know when to step in and when to step back? Maybe you're naturally decisive and find yourself providing answers before others have a chance to contribute. Or maybe you're so committed to giving people freedom that you sometimes leave them without the direction they need. The Compass & Campfire Leadership Guide will help you recognize when your team needs clear direction and when they need more room to contribute, make decisions, and grow. Download the Free Compass & Campfire Leadership Guide → Do you ever wish you could take back something you said—or regret something you didn't? Maybe you respond too quickly when you're frustrated. Or perhaps you spend so much time processing your thoughts that you miss opportunities to speak up or address something important. The Leadership Response Filter gives you four practical questions to help you think intentionally, choose your timing, and communicate constructively. Download the Free Leadership Response Filter → You don't have to overhaul your leadership overnight. Start with one behavior, practice it intentionally, and pay attention to how it changes the way you lead. Small adjustments, practiced consistently, can make a meaningful difference in the people you lead.